When Rich LaDieu received a speed camera ticket from College Park he Knew he hadn't been speeding, his car told him so. LaDieu had a device called a CarChip plugged into the OBDII interface under his dash. "It records everything the computer sees in the engine, transmission, emissions, sensors, and most important your current speed every five seconds."
The citation (#cp10316438) cited LaDieu for driving 48mph in a 35mph zone on Painted Branch parkway. Ladieu went to his car chip and pulled data for the date and time shown on the citation. The data contained both speeds at specific intervals(see speed interval data), showing that at the specific time on the citation he was not traveling at the speed shown. It also showed the maximum speed for the 3.9 mile trip: 35mph.
LaDieu received is hearing on April 20, 2011 at 1:15pm in the district Court in Hyattsville, courtroom #6. When he was called to present his case he pointed to the fact that the data from the chip showed both the times at specific intervals, showing the specific time from the citation, including periods with all zeros when the car was stopped at traffic lights, and also the maximum speed for the trip. The Judge handed LaDieu's data to college Park's representative, a Prince George County police officer, who could not explain the data.
The judge became flustered at this point, looking through papers and closely examined LaDieu's citation. But rather than rule on the accuracy of the camera, he then declared that the city had used an "improper filing document". It turns out that most of College Park's cameras are not located in school zones, but rather in "IHE Zones" (Institute of Higher Education) which are not school zones and have no "school zone" signs, but the citation declared the location as a school zone. The judge dismissed the ticket, and then dismissed the citations for ALL the remaining defendants, citing the same reason.
College park has already issued $2.4million worth of speed camera tickets since October, which works out to about 60,000 tickets, or 2.5 tickets ($100) per resident of the town. The city expects their cut of that amount after expenses to be $600,000, equal to about 4.76% of the town's $12.6million annual budget, in just the first 7 months of the program. The remainder goes to Optotraffic/Sigma Space corporation and to pay the PG County officer's who review College Park speed camera tickets (College Park does not maintain its own police force). Presumably most of the ticket recipients did not have chips in their cars recording their speed.
College Park uses the same type of camera as those which are being used in Forest Heights where tickets have been recently been thrown out in court by drivers using time-distance calculations to challenge tickets. StopBigBrotherMD.org has heard from drivers who have received citations from College Park which they believed were in error, but who did not wish to challenge tickets because they felt it would cost them more in lost time that just paying the ticket. Another driver receiving a ticket from the same type of camera in Riverdale Park, even though time-distance calculations showed he was not speeding, decided not to challenge the ticket because it wasn't worth the cost, and didn't want to talk to the press because of concerns about risking reprisals against his business: "They could make my life hell if I p***ed them off" he wrote to us in an email. Meanwhile other drivers in the area who requested hearings have reported long delays getting court hearings. Optotraffic's cameras are based on a proprietary design which does not function like traditional police lidar or radar, and is not listed on the IACP's Conforming Products List of speed enforcement devices.
Fortunately some drivers have now begun standing up for themselves, and judges in Prince George's County are appear to be losing confidence in these cameras. The question is, will the state intervene and begin an investigation into the numerous claims of errors, or will they continue standing idly by and risk innocent drivers who cannot practically defend themselves getting ticketed?
- ► 2016 (21)
- ► 2015 (39)
- ► 2014 (82)
- ► 2013 (102)
- ► 2012 (66)
- Driver Uses CarChip Data to Challenge Optotraffic ...
- Forest Heights Sued County To Get Speed Camera Sit...
- Forest Heights Camera Tickets Fail to Stand Up in ...
- No Spring Break for School Zone Speed Cameras
- New Legislation Covers Scamera Programs' Butt on S...
- Howard County Council Mulling Speed Camera Authori...
- ▼ April 2011 (6)
- ► 2010 (69)
- ► 2009 (58)
Our Top Stories
- Rockville Falsely Accuses School Bus of Speeding
- Montgomery County Has Secret Speed Camera Committee -- Press and Critics Not Welcome
- Montgomery Speed Camera "OmBudsman" Won't Answer Questions
- Montgomery County Issues Erroneous Tickets
- College Park Cited Stationary Bus for Speeding
- Montgomery County ATEU Defends Culture of Secrecy
- How Two-Faced Triple-A Gave Maryland Speed Cameras
- "Secret" Baltimore Speed Camera Audit Found 10% Error Rate
- Speed Camera Reform Act Just a Big Fat Lie
- Court Rules Against Morningside on Public Records Access
- Speed Camera Company Celebrates "Bounty System" Loophole
- Montgomery County Steals Lanes for Expensive Bus Program
- Wicomico County Teachers Say Camera is Not Accurate
- Montgomery Council President Rice Racked Up Tickets
- Circuit Court Rules Innocence is a Defense, Rejects "Snitch" Requirement
- Baltimore Ends Camera Contract, Moves to Hides Records
- Montgomery Scamera Boss Lies About Red Light Camera "Warning Flashes"
- Montgomery County Camera Boss Blocks Public From Secret Meeting
- Salisbury Records Show Calibration Lapses, Sorry No Refunds!!
- Speed Camera Accuracy Questioned in Morningside
- Attorny General Gansler Depicted as "Reckless Passenger"
- Morningside Deployed Cameras Despite County Denial
- Morningside Admits Maintaining No Calibration Records, Doesn't Operate Own Cameras
- ACLU Documents Mass Tracking of Motorists By License Plate Scannrs
- Brekford Demands Tribute to See Calibration Records
- Access To Brekford Calibration Records Stalled in Salisbury, Morningside
- Public and Private Lobbyists Worked to Kill Speed Camera Reform
- Montgomery County Speed Camera Transforms Toyota into Dodge
- Montgomery County Boasts Error Rate "Under Ten Percent"
- Speed Camera Company Collects Dirt on Competitors
- Woman Gets 3 Tickets from DC Without Going There
- Legislature Raises Gas Tax
- Laurel, Hagerstown Circumvent Calibration Requirement
- Speed Camera Calibration Fails To Ensure Accuracy
- Speed Camera Programs Flout Sunshine Law
- Xerox Admits 5% Error Rate For Speed Camera Tickets
- Baltimore Cites Motionless Car For Speeding
- O'Malley Says Speed Camera Bounties Are Illegal
- Baltimore Ticketed Innocent Delivery Vehicle: Documents Prove Speed Camera Error
- Rockville Sees Huge Surge in Red Light Violations
- Trucking Company Challenges Accuracy of Baltimore Citations: Videos Prove Speed Camera Errors
- Speed Camera Salesman Caught Speeding AGAIN
- Riverdale Park Defends Forgery of Police Signatures
- High Court Rules Local Governments Above the Law
- Riverdale Park Allowed Civilians to Forge Police Approvals
- Baltimore Speed Camera Issues Ticket to the Dead
- Statewide Speed Cameras Now a $77Million Per Year Industry
- PG County Court Presumes All Defendants Guilty
- Town Releases Documents Proving Errors With Optotraffic Cameras
- Man arrested for asserting innocence in speed camera hearing
- Optotraffic Representative Caught Speeding
- Driver Uses Carchip to Challenge Optotraffic Camera
- Deceased Baltimore Cop Signs 2000 Citations
- Montgomery County Denies Right To Face Camera Operator In Court
- ACS Buys Steak Dinners For Lawmakers
- Baltimore City Issues Hundreds of Tickets in Error
- Baltimore Writes Speed Camera Revenues Into Budget Before Cameras Approved
- Camera Mistakenly Accuses Driver of 100mph Rampage
- Montgomery County Scamera Contract Includes Massive PR Campaign
- Optotraffic Investigates Possible Speed Camera Errors
- Speed Camera Legislation Attracts Lobbyists
- Sykesville Voters Overturn Speed Cameras in Referendum
- Traffic Engineering Techniques Out-perform Speed Cameras
- Transportation Planning Board Unveils Plan to Track and Tax Drivers